NYC IRS office by Matthew Bisanz
Photo: MBisanz talk / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

What matters

The IRS reports that Treasury and the agency withdrew proposed section 355 provisions, narrowing a 2016 rulemaking without removing other potentially applicable rules. The partial withdrawal took effect October 21, 2026; the bulletin reporting it is dated November 16, 2026.

Verified facts

  • The IRS’s Internal Revenue Bulletin 2026-47 is dated November 16, 2026.
  • According to the IRS bulletin, the action partially withdraws a 2016 proposed rulemaking concerning section 355’s device prohibition and active-trade-or-business requirement.
  • The IRS says the proposals included a “per se” test in proposed § 1.355-2(d)(5) to determine whether a distribution violated the device prohibition.
  • The bulletin states that the Treasury Department and IRS withdrew proposed §§ 1.355-2(d)(2)(iv)(E) and (d)(5), and 1.355-9(d).
  • The IRS identifies October 21, 2026, as the effective date of the partial withdrawal.
  • Treasury and the IRS say the withdrawal does not affect the potential application of other rules or judicial doctrines, including substance-over-form and step-transaction doctrines.

Analysis

Scope: The IRS describes a partial withdrawal of proposed regulations, not a withdrawal of the entire 2016 rulemaking. The identified “per se” test addressed whether a distribution violated the device prohibition. The October 21 effective date and November 16 bulletin date serve different purposes: one dates the withdrawal, while the other dates the publication reporting it.

Editorial opinion

VERXERA opinion: The evidence supports a narrow conclusion: Treasury and the IRS withdrew specified proposals, not the broader framework of potentially applicable rules. Connecting the removal of the proposed “per se” test with the agencies’ express preservation of other rules and judicial doctrines is essential to understanding the action. The October 21, 2026, effective date also distinguishes the change itself from the November 16, 2026, bulletin. The strongest limitation is the withdrawal’s scope: it does not settle how those other rules or doctrines might apply to a distribution. Deeper reading of the cited provisions is worthwhile when that distinction, rather than the announcement alone, is material to understanding the change.

This is VERXERA’s editorial interpretation, separated from the facts and analysis above. The reader keeps the final judgment.

Counterevidence and limits

Treasury and the IRS expressly state that other rules and judicial doctrines remain potentially applicable despite the withdrawal.

Known uncertainties

How other rules or judicial doctrines would apply to a particular distribution is not resolved by this partial withdrawal.